Storico18 novembre 2026

Genetic studies find Ashkenazi Jews share ancestry with other Jewish populations and have mixed Middle Eastern and European ancestry.

David Rosenfeld

David Rosenfeld è lo pseudonimo della redazione Fatti e miti di Hasbara. Gli articoli di questa redazione vengono scritti e pubblicati automaticamente dall’intelligenza artificiale, senza alcuna revisione umana prima della pubblicazione.

Mito

Ashkenazi Jews descend entirely from medieval Khazar converts and have no historical or genetic connection to the Land of Israel.

Fatto

Genetic studies find Ashkenazi Jews share ancestry with other Jewish populations and have mixed Middle Eastern and European ancestry. Research finds no evidence for a significant Khazar contribution, much less an entirely Khazar origin.

The claim that Ashkenazi Jews have no historical or genetic connection to the Land of Israel turns a complicated population history into an all-or-nothing story. Genetic research finds that Ashkenazi Jews share ancestry with other Jewish communities and have both Middle Eastern and European ancestry. It does not support the claim that they are entirely descended from medieval Khazar converts.

How the Khazar story entered modern arguments

The Khazars were a medieval Turkic-speaking power north of the Caucasus. Whether members of its ruling house and wider population adopted Judaism, and how extensive any conversion was, remain historical questions. The Encyclopaedia Iranica account of the Khazars describes sources that place the royal conversion in the ninth century, followed by the ruler’s entourage and some tribal members. It also says the extent is unknown and that Muslim sources described Jews as the smallest religious group. Evidence of a ruler or some Khazars converting cannot establish that the entire Ashkenazi population descends from them.

The all-Khazar origin story is much newer than the medieval events it invokes. Historian Mari Réthelyi, in a study of Hungarian Jewish origin stories, traces a popular version to nineteenth-century Hungarian debates about national origins and notes its revival in Arthur Koestler’s 1974 book The Thirteenth Tribe. In a 2017 YIVO lecture listing, Hebrew University historian Shaul Stampfer discusses the competing accounts and argues that the evidence does not establish a Khazar conversion. These debates show why the distinction matters: a possible conversion in one medieval polity is not proof of a mass migration that replaced the ancestry of European Jews.

Genome studies find more than one source

A 2013 study by Doron Behar and an international team examined 1,774 samples from 106 Jewish and non-Jewish populations, including 261 people from 15 Caucasus-region populations. The researchers compared Ashkenazi Jews with populations across Europe, the Middle East and the region associated with the Khazar Khaganate. Their analysis found Ashkenazi Jews closest to other Jewish groups and to European and Middle Eastern populations; it found no indication of a significant genetic contribution from the Caucasus. The study’s published results also caution that an undetectably small contribution cannot be ruled out. That caveat does not rescue the claim of total Khazar descent: the study identifies Middle Eastern and European ancestry and finds any possible Khazar contribution below a minimal threshold.

Other research reaches the same broad picture while refining its details. A 2017 PLOS Genetics study found that Ashkenazi ancestry is mixed and modeled at least two episodes of European gene flow: one likely from Southern Europe before a late-medieval founder event, and another in Eastern Europe afterward. Its analysis found Middle Eastern as well as European ancestry. The authors note that the timing and sources of migration remain debated because historical records are sparse. That uncertainty concerns how the mixture formed; it does not erase the Middle Eastern component.

Maternal ancestry adds complexity, not support for an exclusively Khazar origin. A 2013 Nature Communications study of Ashkenazi mitochondrial DNA found that four major maternal lineages, together representing about 40 percent of the variation studied, originated in prehistoric Europe. The authors discuss a substantial role for women converting to Judaism in the formation of Ashkenazi communities. A European maternal contribution is compatible with a population shaped by migration, intermarriage and conversion over centuries. It cannot show that every Ashkenazi ancestor came from Europe, still less that the whole population came from Khazaria.

Medieval remains connect past and present

Researchers can compare modern DNA with people who lived in a documented medieval Jewish community. A 2022 study analyzed genome-wide data from 33 people buried in Erfurt, Germany, between about 1270 and 1400. The Cell study of medieval Erfurt Jews found that these individuals were genetically similar to modern Ashkenazi Jews and showed both Middle Eastern and European ancestry. The medieval sample was more varied than the modern population, including groups with different degrees of Eastern European affinity. This offers direct evidence that an established Ashkenazi community in medieval Germany shared ancestry patterns with Jews today, rather than being a population wholly replaced by Khazar converts.

Researchers do not claim that genes assign an individual’s identity or settle political rights. Population genetics estimates ancestry from patterns shared across samples; it cannot reconstruct every ancestor or provide a precise family tree. The evidence does answer the claim’s central factual point: Ashkenazi Jews are not an isolated population with exclusively Khazar ancestry. Historical debates about the scale of Khazar conversion remain distinct from the converging genetic evidence of Middle Eastern and European ancestry shared within Jewish communities.

Fonti

  1. 1
    Khazars - Encyclopaedia Iranicahttps://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/khazars/Non attendibile
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
    No Evidence from Genome-wide Data of a Khazar Origin for the Ashkenazi Jewshttps://web.stanford.edu/group/rosenberglab/papers/BeharEtAl2013-HumBiol.pdfNon attendibile
  5. 5
    The time and place of European admixture in Ashkenazi Jewish historyhttps://journals.plos.org/plosgenetics/article?id=10.1371/journal.pgen.1006644Non attendibile
  6. 6
  7. 7

Impostazioni di accessibilità

Queste impostazioni vengono salvate su questo dispositivo.

Anteprima

Leggi chiaramente, a modo tuo

Personalizza la pagina durante la lettura. Esplora le risorse

Testo
Dimensione del testoSi applica a tutto il sito.
Colore e contrasto
Tema
Movimento
Animazioni«Come il dispositivo» rispetta le impostazioni di riduzione del movimento.